Abstract
Contrast ratio is essential for determining image quality and visual performance, making it a key performance metric for displays. This article explores the differences between static contrast ratio, dynamic contrast ratio, and ambient contrast ratio, emphasizing their impact on the performance of various display technologies, including LCD, OLED, and LED. It also examines how different testing methods and environments impact actual contrast ratios. In addition, this article provides recommendations for selecting high-contrast displays, emphasizing the significance of maximum and minimum brightness and the role of surface reflectivity. The Absen CL series is showcased as an example of how cutting-edge technology can significantly enhance contrast ratios and visual effects.
1. Contrast Ratio: A Key Metric for Image Quality and Visual Performance
The contrast ratio, which measures the difference in brightness between the brightest white and the darkest black on a screen, plays a crucial role in determining image quality and visual performance. A high contrast ratio improves image clarity and vibrancy, enhancing detail, depth, and vividness. In contrast, a low contrast ratio can make images appear dull, blurry, and lacking in depth and dimensionality, making it challenging to distinguish object outlines and details [1].
For instance, in the two photos displayed, a high contrast ratio will enhance the brightness of the white clouds and deepen the color of the grass, thereby creating a scene that is more detailed and vivid.
2 Importance of Contrast Ratio for Displays
For displays, the contrast ratio is a crucial factor that significantly influences how users perceive images and videos. Various display technologies and devices provide different levels of contrast performance. Traditional LCD screens often exhibit lower contrast ratios due to backlight bleed. Conversely, mini-LED screens utilize local dimming technology to effectively mitigate this issue, thereby enhancing the contrast ratio [2]. OLED and LED technologies, featuring self-emissive diodes, avoid backlight bleed, resulting in substantially higher contrast ratios [3].
Apart from the display technology itself, the methods and environments used for testing have a significant impact on the measured contrast ratio. Displays available on the market are evaluated using static contrast ratios, dynamic contrast ratios, and ambient contrast ratios. Despite all being categorized as contrast ratios, the resulting visuals and effects can vary considerably. Many manufacturers promote high contrast ratios, such as 10,000:1 or even 1,000,000:1, without specifying the type of contrast ratio or providing details on measurement methods and environments. This contributes to customer confusion, as the actual visual performance often fails to meet expectations [4]. Therefore, how can we identify displays that truly deliver high performance amidst exaggerated claims? First, we need to understand the distinctions between static contrast, dynamic contrast, and ambient contrast ratios.
3 Types of Contrast Ratios
Static contrast ratios: The static contrast ratio measures the ratio between the brightness of the brightest white and the darkest black that a display can simultaneously showcase. For LCD displays, the backlight imposes limitations on achieving the darkest black, thereby resulting in a lower static contrast ratio. In self-emissive displays such as OLED and LED, each pixel can be individually controlled and completely turned off, which enables achieving extremely high static contrast ratios. These ratios can theoretically approach infinity [5]
Dynamic contrast ratios: The dynamic contrast ratio measures the disparity between the brightness of the brightest white and the darkest black across varying time intervals. Achieving this typically involves adjusting the backlight or pixel brightness to enhance the visual effects of the image. LCD displays utilize backlight dimming for darker scenes and brightening for brighter scenes, significantly increasing the dynamic contrast ratio compared to the static contrast ratio. Nevertheless, excessively high dynamic contrast may lead to image distortion. Self-emissive displays achieve enhanced dynamic contrast ratios mainly through algorithms and advanced image processing technologies, particularly when handling high dynamic range (HDR) content.
Şekil 3 Dinamik Kontrast Oranları
In summary, the static contrast ratio indicates the hardware capabilities of a display. On the other hand, the dynamic contrast ratio is influenced by the manufacturer’s algorithms and image processing technologies. For LCD displays, the disparity between static and dynamic contrast ratios is significant and merits careful consideration. In self-emissive displays such as OLED and LED, while there remains a distinction between static and dynamic contrast ratios, this difference is less perceptible during actual use due to the inherent advantages of the technology.
4 The Importance of Ambient Contrast Ratio
As previously mentioned, self-emissive displays such as OLED and LED can achieve theoretically infinite contrast ratios by completely turning off pixels to display black. However, this theoretical capability does not mean that all OLED and LED displays, regardless of their maximum brightness, will consistently deliver the same infinite contrast ratio and visual impact in real-world conditions. Theoretical contrast ratios are measured in dark rooms. However, in practical usage, ambient light significantly influences the contrast ratio [6]. It is well known that even high-contrast displays can appear less impressive under strong ambient light. Due to the varying levels of ambient light in different display environments, the ambient contrast ratio provides a more accurate reflection of actual display performance.
The ambient contrast ratio measures a display’s contrast performance in real-world environments. Ambient light increases the brightness of the black screen, thereby reducing the ambient contrast ratio compared to both static and dynamic contrast ratios. The established industry standard for testing ambient contrast ratio involves measuring it at illuminances below 10 lux. In such scenarios, depending on the surface characteristics of the screen, self-emissive displays such as OLED and LED usually exhibit ambient contrast ratios ranging from 5,000 to 10,000, significantly below their theoretical values. To give you an idea of how bright 10 lux is, here are some examples of lux levels in common scenes [7]:
It’s evident that 10 lux signifies a fairly dim environment. When using a display with a nominal contrast ratio of 10,000 in brighter settings like homes or offices, the actual contrast ratio may drop to approximately 2,000, significantly reducing the quality of the viewing experience.
4 Recommendations for High Contrast Displays
Having explained the various types of contrast ratios and how different display technologies handle them, it’s essential to understand which specific type of contrast ratio a manufacturer is referencing and the ambient light conditions under which these measurements were taken. Comparisons only hold significance when contrast ratios are measured under identical conditions. In theory, higher contrast ratios equate to better display performance. Nevertheless, even measurements taken under the same 10 lux lighting conditions can yield different results for the same display due to differences in testing environments and methodologies. For instance, two manufacturers could both advertise the same contrast ratio, but the actual display quality may differ significantly between their products. Alternatively, claimed contrast ratios might show notable differences, yet real-world performance might reveal minimal distinctions. This variance is largely attributed to viewing angles, which directly influence the actual contrast. Various testing methods, such as the positioning of the light source, display panel, and measurement sensor, can lead to considerable discrepancies in recorded contrast ratio values.
For instance, even under identical brightness and incidence angles, measuring from different angles can produce varying contrast data. Similarly, maintaining a fixed sensor position while varying the angles and positions of incidence will also result in different contrast data [8]. Typically, manufacturers specify ambient illuminance and fix the relative positions of the sensor and screen. However, due to the inability to completely standardize light source distributions across different laboratories, contrast ratio measurements may vary. Therefore, the manufacturer’s nominal contrast ratio should only be considered as a point of reference.
How can consumers reliably select a display with a superior contrast ratio? Which types of displays or specific parameters (unaffected by different measurement methods) consistently indicate higher contrast performance across different environments? It all depends on the fundamental concept of contrast ratio: the ratio between a display’s maximum and minimum brightness [9].
The simplest and most direct approach is to choose displays with a higher maximum brightness. Typically, higher maximum brightness correlates with higher contrast ratios. This is particularly important for outdoor displays. LCD screens, which typically have maximum brightness in the range of a few hundred nits, show almost no contrast ratios under bright outdoor lighting. On the other hand, outdoor LED displays can achieve brightness levels up to 10,000 nits, maintaining high contrast ratios even under direct midday sunlight to ensure clear display quality. In contrast, excessively high brightness in indoor displays can be glaring and cause eye strain during prolonged viewing periods. Therefore, increasing contrast ratios through high brightness is less practical for indoor screens in terms of viewing comfort. For indoor displays, peak brightness and image processing algorithms can dynamically adjust local brightness to prevent excessive brightness that causes glare [10].
Another approach involves selecting displays with lower minimum brightness levels, thereby achieving higher contrast ratios. For LCDs and other backlit displays, adjusting the backlight significantly impacts the minimum brightness. In self-emissive displays like LEDs, the screen’s reflectance directly affects the minimum brightness. Reflectance is an objective parameter that indicates the degree of light reflection and remains unaffected by ambient light intensity or angle. This property is measured using standard instruments to ensure consistent surface reflectance, regardless of variations in measurement methods among different manufacturers. Therefore, for displays with the same maximum brightness, those with lower surface reflectance will exhibit a higher actual contrast ratio [11].
In conclusion, when choosing a display, particularly an LED one, comparing the maximum brightness and surface reflectance among various models will effectively indicate which display provides a higher contrast ratio in real-world settings.
